Quote:
Originally Posted by guiri
Quote:
Originally Posted by Archangel
That leaves Silver Jan and Three, and makes me more nervous about Three, because SJ's claim such as it is seems too far-fetched to be made up out of whole cloth.
|
What's far-fetched about SJ's claim?
#98 Visited lulz, not nefarious
#100 Looks like lulz was not NK target
#141 Is not the doc
#157 Is not roleblocker
#290 Banishment will reveal three things about her role
#291 Has a role
#296 Is not a roleblocker
#345 Is human, is Mary Winchester
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silver Jan
What I did learn was that it doesn't look as if Lulz was the target of a NK, which seems pretty obvious at this time seeing as Archangel was killed. I don't want to say too much right now because although my role isn't all powerful, it could be helpful down the road.
|
Her claim that she learned Maha was not the target of a NK is interesting since Maha claims he was trying to kill Lulz. Of course we currently believe Maha made a false claim but this would indicate he's not even a killer, or that SJ's claim is also fake. |
Farfetched isn't the right word, I suppose. It's too detailed and specific to be a made-up-out-of-thin-cloth claim. Of course now I've said this someone will come up with some game where scum made up a role entirely * and won that way...but these super-specific claims I tend to think are real for the most part, and if they are scum they are just changing a detail or two.
(Although I suppose scum might also be claiming each other's roles-- I've seen that done before successfully.)
I guess it comes down to whether or not there's another roleblock tonight, but I can hold my tongue another day. I'm saying neither Mahaloth's or Jan's claims make me think they're town, but they also don't make me think they're roleblockers.