View Single Post
  #53  
Old 9th August 2015, 07:16 AM
Archangel's Avatar
Archangel Archangel is offline
She/Her/Hers
 
Join Date: May 2009
Location: At large, but currently near NYC
Posts: 8,227
Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by idrinkthere4iam View Post

I'm not going to provide exact posts. As I don't them, I'm posting from my phone, and it's not specific posts that make me suspicious. It's your general behavior in this game. Everyone expects you to mix it up and try to confuse everyone, but more importantly the Scum. I've only played with you once before but that's seems to be your style and from what I gather from others I think I'm right. But this game you just stand out as a little over the top. Maybe I'm wrong, only time will tell, and like I said, I've only played with you once, so that's not a lot to go on. But it's that, which made you rise on the list from hovering around the middle.
I want people to seriously consider these words.

What posts or behaviors are suspicious?

No specific posts, just my behavior in the game.

What behavior? What am I doing which is scummy behavior? Why is it scummy behavior and not townie behavior?

What goes through your brain that makes you think why, pizza isn't being a villager, he's a scumbag.

And why does it make you think that.

Nothing, no process, no explanation for why you think the way you do.

Pizza is scummy because I've played with pizza once before and from what I'm gathering from others (Who?) my style is to "confuse people".

I'm pretty sure I haven't been stuttering this game or saying anything too convoluted.

I think X and Y are villagers, and this is why I think that way. I do not want them to die. I have no special knowledge. I do not want to lynch these people because they do not fit what I understand scumbags to do, for these specific reasons.

How come I can say all these things but all drinkiepoo has to say about me is that I am suspicious because I am over the top.

What does that mean?

What general behaviors are we talking about? We're being generic about generic overall suspicion.

Quote:
Hopefully that satisfies you. If not, then go ahead and vote for me tomorrow. I don't give into scare tactics and I will not take your word as gospel until proof is provided. And no, because you "know" something isn't proof enough for me.
Can anyone tell me how this is a thought in a mafia game that villagers have after I claimed to be vanilla?

"I don't give into scare tactics." No, but you hopped and danced real quick when I told you to come up with reasons why I'm suspicious, the one thing you won't do is provide actual content, just the most generic non-answer that has been provided by any player, under any circumstance, since the game began.

"I will not take your word as gospel until proof is provided".

Oh good, well at least I know where the bar is. If I can get the game host to admit that Scathach is scum, then you will take my word as gospel.

Good to know!

What proof does a vanilla townie provide?

Let me know.

I could always provide you with the same level of answer you're giving here.

Scathach is suspicious because of her general behavior this game, which even though I haven't played with her in a while, I understand to be suspicious. Unnamed others feel the same way. I can't say what she's doing that's so suspicious and I'm not saying she's scum, not at all, just that she is suspicious for her behavior, which I have yet to specify. I will suggest that her behavior is "under the top."

I won't be bullied into thinking otherwise, with all your scare tactics of asking solving questions!

My word, it's just not proper behavior in a game such as this.

You are directing a witch hunt sir, and I want no part of that! Now excuse me while I vote for someone who is acting like a villager, repeatedly, because it tickles my fancy to do so.

You are a cardboard cut-out of a villager, but there's nothing underneath. And the resolution is hardly life-like.

I'm pretty sure setting you on fire will cure you of all your ills, drink.
Pizza, you've convinced me that you're town, and that lulz is, so take everything I say in that context.

I read Idrinkthere4Iam's responses to you and to me and I drew the opposite conclusion you did. He seems to be getting genuinely frustrated which leads me to believe he's more likely town than scum. (The only thing I'm good at as town is figuring out who's frustrated town FWIW.)

I also don't think it makes sense with him as scum to just say you're suspicious without itemizing the reasons. More specifically, he's got a pretty good (from the standpoint of reasonableness, not from accuracy) reason for thinking you're scum-- you didn't move your vote to save Lightfoot after she claimed. I understand what you're saying about why you didn't do that, but this is a reasonable explanation for suspecting you. IMO scum come up with something reasonable to say and then hold onto it like a dog with a bone.

Him getting frustrated and being unable to come up with a specific example reads WAY more town to me than scum.