Ok so my reads/leans:
Lulz - Probably town. I never saw the scum other people were seeing in him and as the game has progressed he's just seemed more and more townie in his reactions to poeple (particularly his post where he questions Lightfoot's mechanics post although I also agree with archangel that Lightfoot does that as town too).
AskthePizzaGuy: Scummish. Not entirely OMGUS although maybe partially. I don't particularly mind him thinking I'm scum but I don't like his complete certainty and I especially don't like how all of town seems to be dancing to his tune. He's doing a lot of guilt tripping (Why will no one contribute???) in order to get people to vote the way he wants them to. Then again, he's Pizza and certainty is his stock in trade.
DizzyMrsLizzy focused on lulz quite a lot but yet accused him of not answering questions that he had in fact answered. While (obviously) I can sympathise with tunnelling to an extent, when I tunnelled I was combing through all of Double A's posts. It's weird to me that she would be so convinced he was scum and not pay a lot of attention to what he was saying. Scummy.
Meeko - would have said scummy but I tend to give claims the benefit of the doubt.
Guiri was the only person who seemed to see what I was talking about with Double A, but ironically I actually think he's scummy this game. I honestly can't put my finger on why.
SisterCoyote - her day 1 was fine, but I don't really like todays bandwagon vote. She's said she's busy with IRL stuff though so *shrugs*
Mahaloth I'm flip flopping on but on balance I think could be scummy.
Sooh and Sario I keep mixing up (sorry!) so I'm currently completely neutral on both.
Bill never posts enough for me to get a good read on him, but I'm leaning town.
Idrinkthere4iam - I very much sympathise with his argument that it's not scummy to try and look reasonable. Maybe there are people who play totally unconcernedly as villager but no matter what role I have in mafia I am always vastly overthinking everything I say.
|