[LightFoot]

Quoting Double A

I don't know, but if Pizza was converted mid-night then it would fly in the face of literally all the precedent set over the past, I dunno, decade? by our group's hosting culture and tendencies. Visor himself has personally never done anything of the sort. I know he said don't take other games into account, but I would find it impossibly hard to believe that Pizza was given his mafia role PM before anyone else got a nightly results PM at the start of D2. I would wager he was town for a bit longer than one night, but given the fact that he was converted, I am 99.99% certain he was a townie the first day and night, and everything he said should be taken at face value.

Actual conversion would only happen when the player notices they have a PM and reads it