[Suburban Plankton]

Originally Posted by LightFoot

In my case, is it based only on the Commissar results? Or is there something else ?

Not, not only the Commissar result, although that did play into it. You've spent a lot of time trying to tell us how the game should be played: who the Commissar should investigate, how we should elect roles. You keep coming up with 'plans' and 'ideas' for the Town to follow. You admonish us all for not 'Scum hunting', but I haven't seen any accusations coming from you.

You have been extremely 'helpful', but haven't produced much of any substance. I find that suspicious.

Originally Posted by Silverjan

I find your vote for the kill a little bit odd. Both Maha and LightFoot have been commissar and their targets were NK'd and yet you choose to kill someone who hasn't done anything except say that they don't mind being investigated. SNF is, in my opinion, the least likely choice for a lynch (of your 3 scum leans). I suppose people play differently but it does make me curious as to your choice.

There was something about the phrasing of this statement

Originally Posted by SNFaulkner

I welcome an investigation on me for any and all reasons.

that set off alarm bells in my head - call it a hunch if you will. And since we're not actually voting to kill anyone, but simply voting to tell someone else who they should kill, i don't see anything terribly wrong with playing hunches. if a sufficient number of people agree with me, then maybe it's 'more than a hunch'; if not, then there's no harm done.