The Giraffe Boards - View Single Post - Yeetmas 3 - Day 2

Meeko · #47 30th December 2021, 07:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

Spoiled here is the entire post that starts with ::

What I am seeing that can just be normal Guiri but pings me is as follows:

That read on Guiri is difficult. Trying a second read.

What I am seeing that can just be normal Guiri but pings me is as follows:

Note where his focus is, in his posts. Read all of them in chronological order.

https://www.giraffeboards.com/showth...97#post1738197
This is basically fluff. And it is post 57 of d1 so, who cares about that.

Post 102 however is attempting to null multiple person's arguments, fluff, and mechanics. Thats an easy way to coast through the game without triggering alarm bells. So scums do this a lot. This and some others pinged me.
https://www.giraffeboards.com/showth...38#post1738338

https://www.giraffeboards.com/showpo...&postcount=164
This post looks solidly in villager range. There is some investigation, some clarification, some 'lack of TMI', and multiple aggressions. That's pretty concentrated villagery.

213 looks like the reading non-comprehension towntell from Silverjan, which is significant as it hasnt been wrong yet.

https://www.giraffeboards.com/showth...31#post1738631
216 looks villagery brainwave.

https://www.giraffeboards.com/showpo...&postcount=218
218 is a good follow up to interrogative with Silverjan. Seems like he is trying to get answers and act on them during the round, rather than skate.

So that, I take away more villagery than wolfy on the second pass.

I see where there is generic and fluffy and skatey, but there are serious counterindicators. Checking d2 again.

After the initial quoting of the vote tally, I see he does a multiquote wall of raven.

Now, I disagree with the conclusion that any of that is out of sorts for raven. This is what I have come to expect from town raven, in several examples.

People have real lives, and some players are not hardcore solvers, gotta solve every post as town, thats not how raven flies.

So I take it as an easy case a scum can make, but Guiri isnt satisfied with plopping an easy vote on raven after case walling her here.
https://www.giraffeboards.com/showpo...72&postcount=7

I dont know if I am there on Mord, but I am running out of spaces for townies to be.
This spreads the aggression and the case makes sense from a not-me POV and some generics of what I also believe.
https://www.giraffeboards.com/showth...74#post1739174

12 and 13 of that thread is the waterfall / continuing thoughts towntell from Guiri, which I should have noticed on the first pass. It indicates a seriousness of belief and a real time solving and processing and behaving indicative of natural townies.

https://www.giraffeboards.com/showpo...3&postcount=14
This also makes sense as a continuing solving process. Not only that, the push on silverjan reads as non-agendy assuming exactly Jan and Guiri are not a scum team together. It's a good nuance to pick up on, which scums tend to forget about.

34 again reads just fine and trying to solve for someones alignment by asking questions rather than being lazy and generic, particularly wrt the interactions with dizzy.

That is quite high level scum acting from guiri if it is.

36 is excellent. I can't get much from gnarlycharlie, still, but what stuff I was finding that was scummy about guiri is far more generic than the counterarguments I am able to generate on closer inspection and slower reading comprehension.

There are town tells in play here that indicate much more strongly against a Guiri vote today. Glad I rechecked all this, missed all of it on the first pass, looking for reasons to case Guiri.

Its hard to both attack and defend someone at the same time, you really have to shut off one to fairly do the other.

Respectfully, you are doing like, Calculus here. My brain flaked out around like Algebra II. Legit don't know why I need to know binomials and quadratic equations.

Like,

Am I supposed to be playing like this (Do we have a " gulp " emoji?)