9th January 2022, 08:11 AM
|
 |
Shenanigangster
|
|
Join Date: Jan 2016
Location: Chateau Pepperwinkle
Posts: 6,190
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silverjan
Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
That plan doesn't ever work when gnarlycharlie is scum, however, because then town does have exactly the right amount of townies to win, because then gnarly is a scum inactive as opposed to a townie inactive.
If scums cannot reliably outvote town because town lost people at night and have 2 inactives during day, they have to try to kill Vanta Black and the town Doctor.
And without being able to just out themselves and say who is killing who without drawing a vig shot from Vanta Black, they had to play a guessing game as to who should shoot the doctor and whether to shoot Prof P or Vanta Black as one of them was likely to be protected.
If they each decided the other team would hit the town Doc, then they both went for one of the two other town PRs, and only one of those would be protected at a time, but one of them would be and neither team would know if the other team was hitting the other target, so those targets overlapped.
They kind of guessed the other team would hit Doctor, and then both made the same town PR choice as a target, as opposed to one and the other, guaranteeing one death.
So they both guessed exactly incorrectly.
Its also not farfetched that Dizzy realized she couldnt shoot me anymore, and therefore changed her target before deadline after trying to coordinate with the opposing team by signalling she was shooting me, which would tell the other team to shoot the town Doctor.
It is still a bit baffling that neither team would shoot the doc.
|
It's not baffling at all if the "so called" doc was really scum and was protected. There is just no other explanation for it. Scum team 1 would protect Pleo but scum team 2 wouldn't know he was scum and so they tried to kill him, meanwhile scum team 1 tried to kill Vanta. |
Yes, that makes much more sense.
|