[Askthepizzaguy]

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

Gnarly has to be Elf Shelf all the time. It isn't Meeko, it isn't Plankton, and it isn't me, and I think Mord is Mariah, not Elf.

I went over why in previous posts, but if you're following along and don't remember / tldr the previous posts, here's why.

1) Meeko should have shot Jan last night, which is the obvious shot, and also because when he doesn't, that creates enough kill power for town for town to actually vig meeko on Night 6. Meeko doesn't read as scum, and especially doesn't read as Elf Shelf particularly because BC would have been reaching out after outing and trying to form an alliance with Meeko, who responded by simply voting for him and calling for him to be vigged, rather than coordinate kill power. It doesn't prove he isn't Mariah, but by cold read, he's not scum, and if he's not scum, he's not Mariah. 2) A Poor Shepherd Boy called for Plankton to be vigged. I went over why that's extremely poor to do, it outs Plankton as being protected at all, and Prof P is still alive to scan you, and APSB was under suspicion and a target for both scan and vig. You don't suicide your whole faction like that, no matter how much an inactive teammate frustrates you. 3) Mordenkainen would have placed a duh-shot for Jan last night because he was active at deadline of previous day. He wasn't inactive, so the missing shot doesn't make sense coming from him unless he's extremely poor at shooting the one person in the game who is always hostile to him and cannot be protected at all. Sorry, I don't think Mordenkainen is that bad at the game. I think he's Mariah almost all the time, and town when I guessed wrong, NEVER Elf shelf anymore. 4) I am the holder of the "It's Not Askthepizzaguy" card. 5) Jan is an awesome badass town doctor. 6) Vanta is an awesome badass town vig.

Like Bashorian Clement, it is possible to determine Gnarlycharlie's role and alignment exactly even if I messed up elsewhere.