3rd January 2023, 12:11 PM
|
 |
Charter Member
|
|
Join Date: Mar 2010
Posts: 3,057
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Swammerdami
I just re-read the game, playing attention to Bashorian mentions and Bashorian's posts.
The first thing that stood out was that I caught BC in a (weak?) scum tell Day 1, then forgot about it.  Renata pointed this out:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Renata
This [Swammi] is very unlikely to be a town player. Aside from the push on Pizza and everything that came of that, there is no interest shown in solving the game. There's no process on anything. Pizza was 100% scum, then "did he actually claim vig?" and 100% unvote, no interest in anybody else. Original scum read on Bashorian Clement entirely forgotten, doesn't follow through on APSB wagon, doesn't find an alternative vote. Shows ten times as much interest today in the mechanics questions than in anything to do with solving.
|
I agree with her; and the post makes me lean strongly Town on her. (She's right about my play being atrocious if Town ... but of course she's wrong about me actually being scum!)
Something else that stood out very clearly is that Burma Shave is definitely not an Elf. (I still think he's a top candidate for Mariah Godfather.)
Raventhief and APSB are the players who voted BC for the successful Wrap. They are unlikely to be Elves.
Finally, here are Miko's (most recent?) leans
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Miko
Elves
Bashorian
One of <Lightfoot/TexCat>
One of <Raven/Jackie>
Mariah
One of <Burma/Raven>
|
TexCat voted for the Mariah scum (Burma Shave) but has refused to take a stand on the Elves.
I move that we Double Wrap TexCat (Elf) and Burma Shave (Mariah). |
I did vote Raven yesterday. I would be happy for her to be the second lynch today, but I'm bet-the-ranch sure that Burma is the mariah godfather and only bet-you-a-nickel sure about Raven.
|