View Single Post
  #42  
Old 13th November 2012, 10:30 AM
guiri's Avatar
guiri guiri is offline
Charter Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Posts: 2,685
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chucara View Post
If Squid flips scum as expected, I think we can win by looking at two things: the vote record, and looking at who got beaten up when certain people were on a mission.
What will we learn about the beatings if Squid flips scum that we can't deduce now?

- N1 someone beat Peeker, possibly Colby but probably not - two scum beaters would be a giveaway - so Bill and I are not beaters
- N2 someone double-beat Giraffe, not Scuba
- N3 no-one reported any beatings, I suspect the mission caused some sort of block
- N4 no-one reported any beatings except Chucara - which may have been related to my roleblock (otherwise what's the likelihood...)
- N5 Total reported a double beating, again not Scuba
- N6 no-one's claimed anything. Like N3, given what we know about KidV and Ulla's alignment, it's possible that Giraffe and the scum beater were blocked last Night - put to sleep

So, of the remaining players the potential beaters are:
- Crys, unlikely, proven Private, claimed Vanilla
- MHaye, possible, claimed Sergeant but Vanilla
- Chucara, unlikely, could have false-claimed N4 beating but claimed before I reported
- Bill, nope
- Scuba, double nope
- Squid, possible, claimed Corporal but Vanilla