#1
|
|||
|
|||
NFL Expansion and hypothetical schedule
If the NFL swallowed up the CFL, and added 4 teams, here's how I'd align the teams, and do the schedule. Tell me what you think:
AFC EAST NEW ENGLAND NEW YORK JETS BUFFALO TORONTO BALTIMORE PITTSBURGH AFC CENTRAL JACKSONVILLE MIAMI INDIANAPOLIS CLEVELAND CINCINNATI TENNESSEE AFC WEST HOUSTON KANSAS CITY DENVER EDMONTON LAS VEGAS LOS ANGELES CHARGERS NFC EAST WASHINGTON PHILADELPHIA NEW YORK GIANTS CAROLINA ATLANTA TAMPA BAY NFC CENTRAL DETROIT CHICAGO GREEN BAY MINNESOTA WINNIPEG NEW ORLEANS NFC WEST DALLAS ARIZONA LOS ANGELES RAMS SAN FRANCISCO SEATTLE BRITISH COLUMBIA Schedule: 18 games (h/h in division, 1 division in conference, 2 interconference games, based on record) Season starts the Sunday of the long weekend Teams play first 6 games without a bye, last 6 without a bye, 1 bye/season SNF/MNF DH every weekend Other than the night you're avoiding your annoying relatives, no more TNF Saturday (1/wk) games starting Week 13 (1st week after byes finish) No more "Breakfast at Wembly" or Mexico City games 7 playoff teams per conference playoff schedule remains the same otherwise Pro Bowl AFTER SB Non-schedule related changes Draft goes to 8 rounds No more compensatory picks Time limits go 20/15/10/5 (2 rds each level) Draft is 2 days 1st overall pick goes on the clock at high noon local time on last Saturday in April (4 rds/day) Last edited by etv78; 4th August 2019 at 09:19 PM. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Snark or sincere? Would you change anything?
|
#3
|
||||
|
||||
Oh, Nominal will change something. Give him a little time.
|
#4
|
|||
|
|||
I bet he'll change the alignment, due to lost rivalries
|
#5
|
||||
|
||||
Yeah, rivalries will need to be maintained -- Cleveland vs. Pittsburgh stands out to me as being missing in that alignment -- and some of the realignments just don't make sense. How on earth is the Atlantic coast of Florida "central"? I'm all in favor of bending geography to keep rivalries, that's why Dallas is in the NFC East after all, but some of that just doesn't make any sense.
I'd come up with my own version, but that sounds too much like thinking. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
True JJ. Teams I expect to be most aggrieved:
Pittsburgh Miami Dallas Atlanta What do you think of my schedule and draft changes? |
#7
|
||||
|
||||
(This is not response to your plan for CFL/NFL integration)
For many years, I have been tossing around a plan to address several different 'problems' in the NFL that various stakeholders complain about.
So, for this season it would look like something like this: Week 1: Cardinals vs. 49ers Week 2: Jets vs. Raiders (Cardinals and 49ers on added bye) Week 3: Buccaneers vs. Giants (Jets and Raiders on added bye) Week 4: Jaguars vs. Lions (Buccaneers and Giants on added bye) Week 5: Bills vs. Broncos (Jaguars and Lions on added bye) Week 6: Bengals vs. Packers (Bills and Broncos on added bye) Week 7: Dolphins vs. Falcons (Bengals and Packers on added bye) Week 8: Redskins vs. Panthers (Dolphins and Falcons on added bye) Week 9: Browns vs. Vikings (Redskins and Panthers on added bye) Week 10: Titans vs. Steelers (Browns and Vikings on added bye) Week 11: Seahawks vs. Ravens (Titans and Steelers on added bye) Week 12: Texans vs. Bears (Seahawks and Ravens on added bye) Week 13: Eagles vs. Colts (Texans and Bears on added bye) Week 14: Cowboys vs. Chargers (Eagles and Colts on added bye) Week 15: Chiefs vs. Saints (Cowboys and Chargers on added bye) Week 16: Rams vs. Patriots (Chiefs and Saints on added bye) Week 17: (Rams and Patriots on added bye) Week 18: Penultimate week of the regular season Week 19: Final week of the regular season |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Pogo: other than making the London games 1v32, 2v31, etc, I'd be interested in your newsletter.
|
#9
|
||||
|
||||
The problem with 1v32 , 2v31, etc. is that many of the games would be low quality blowouts. Cardinals vs Patriots would not be expected to be close. By doing 1v2, 3v4, each game would be expected to be close.
Extra: Many folks nationwide are surprised to learn that I like some sports more than the NFL football. I am from Pittsburgh and I had two great uncles who played in the league. But I always say that the NFL is one of the three best sports leagues in the world, probably the best. What makes it the best? Event watching (only 16 games mean that each is so important) and every fanbase has hope each year. What gives each fanbase hope? Changes can happen quickly because the league is communistic. Revenues are shared, there's a salary cap, there's a salary floor, and the worse teams get the easier schedules. This last bit used to be more prominent, but due to realignment, there are now only two games in each team's schedule that are based on their record. 1v2 through 31v32 continues this mindset. The worst teams would have reason to believe they could win those games, all of 'em! All of the games should be close. If we went 1v32 through 16v17, we would be donating free wins to the best teams while blowing out the worst teams. And the teams from near the playoff cutoff would be required to play a tough game, e.g. 16v17. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Pogo: care to actually address the OP?
|
#11
|
||||
|
||||
I'll make a few posts, although it won't end up as your NFL/CFL merger. 10-20 years ago, I had a few thoughts, made a few files, and sent a few emails to my sports friends about realignment and such, mostly within the NFL.
The first topic I'll go with (in the rest of this post) had to do with cross-conference rivals. Part of this idea had to do with a different (not my later London thoughts) 17th regular season game. NCAA leagues that have multiple divisions have cross-divisional games. In almost all cases, a team will not play every team on the other side. Rather, they play a few one year, a few the next year, etc., in a rotational pattern so that they eventually play all of the teams. However, sometimes, there is a protected rivalry such that one pairing is played every year. Back before interleague play in baseball, the Yankees would play the Mets, in an in-season exhibition game for the Mayor's Trophy. I believe it was played during the All-Star break and featured the two teams minus their All-Stars (who would have been at the All-Star game.) These situations made me think about Cross-Conference rivalries in the NFL. These games would be played every year as a 17th game. I thought through who the rivalries would be and there were only a few tough ones. Here we go: Easy ones:
Getting harder:
Toughest (we are left with MIN, ATL, CIN, NE):
|
#12
|
||||
|
||||
How would this idea work today?
Easy ones:
Getting harder:
Toughest (we are left with MIN, ATL, CIN, NE):
|
#13
|
|||
|
|||
So basically, you will just continually ignore my OP? Even when I SPECIFICALLY ask you to address it?!
|
#14
|
||||
|
||||
This post will be about the NFL realignment in 2002. At that time, I thought some changes (that weren't made) should have been made.
Baltimore -> Miami -> Indianapolis -> Baltimore I think Baltimore fits well in the AFC East while Miami does not. Buffalo and Miami (arguably) hate each other the most, but I think Miami fits much better in the AFC South. Meanwhile Indianapolis lies super close to all of (the rest of) the AFC North. So, I moved Baltimore to Miami's slot in the AFCE, Miami to Indianapolis' slot in the AFCS, and Indianapolis to Baltimore's slot in the AFCN. Carolina <-> Dallas Dallas has fought in the past to remain in the NFC East, and lots of powerful teams like playing those relatively old rivalries but Dallas shouldn't be there. So I switched 'em Houston <-> Tampa Bay Atlanta <-> Tennessee Nothing too drastic here, but moving these four makes their divisions work better Seattle <-> Kansas City San Francisco <-> Denver Realignment forced the breakup of the AFC West and the NFL chose Seattle to be out. If they had broken it up differently (3 and 2 instead of 4 and 1) they could have had better geography. The new divisions: AFC West (all Pacific coast, some AFC West and Bay action):
AFC North (geographically tight):
AFC South (Florida and nearby Atlanta):
AFC East (northeast):
NFC West (Missouri and the Mountain Time Zone plus some AFC West)
NFC North (no changes)
NFC South (Texas, former Texas, close to Texas):
NFC East (just like it says, it's the NFC, Eastern teams):
|
#15
|
||||
|
||||
No, I am getting there through my old posts.
|
#16
|
||||
|
||||
Today's version of this realignment would be almost the same. The only change would be switching Vegas (Oakland) for Los Angles Rams (St. Louis).
|
#17
|
||||
|
||||
Since you want me on that topic.
In short, I see no way that the NFL would merge with the CFL or the remains of the CFL, should the CFL disappear. Today is unlike the environment of the NFL/AFL merger. Furthermore, the NFL likes the CFL as a minor league. If the NFL needed expansion, they would rather choose their own expansion cities and get true expansions even if those franchises are in the same cities as CFL teams looking for a post-CFL home. In the mid-nineties, the CFL expanded to the US including the Baltimore Stallions. Once Baltimore secured the theft of the NFL's Browns, the Stallions - the defending Grey Cup Champions - folded and the ownership moved to Montreal. I know this is the reverse of your proposal, but it shows the drastic difference in popularity between the NFL and the CFL. |
#18
|
||||
|
||||
I will skip my next expected post about scheduling to go to my expansion/realignment stuff.
I propose an expansion of eight teams giving 8 divisions of 5 teams apiece (instead of your four team expansion to 6 divisions of 6 teams each.) Prime expansion candidates included:
AFC West
|
#19
|
||||
|
||||
It'll take a while for me to use my updated realignment with expansion of eight teams, if I even do it. Now, I will mention the schedule ideas (no 17th game, no expansion.) These ideas are mine and three of my former co-workers as we debated this issue back in ~2002.
I noted that I was disappointed that only two games are dictated by how well a team had performed. Real Schedule:
My schedule idea with more games dictated by how well a team had performed:
My friend Mark's liked my concept for more games depending on performance but he didn't really get with harder schedule for better teams, easier schedule for worse teams so he adjusted my table:
Jeff saw what we were saying and he chose to throw away the cross-conference-complete-division play. Instead, he effectively ended conferences altogether at least until the playoffs.
My boss Pete never liked the communistic NFL (he is English so he is used to powerhouse dynasty soccer.) Here is his idea:
Well, those were the schedule ideas. Most are easily expandable for differently-sized divisions, should expansion take place. |
#20
|
||||
|
||||
Now that I got through the NFL portions of my old files (failing my creation of a modern realignment with expansion since St. Louis, San Diego, and Oakland have moved/are moving) I will make more notes on your initial post.
If the CFL failed and the NFL decide to integrate four teams. I think you did pretty good with six divisions of six teams each. I can see historical success reasons to take Edmonton and Winnipeg, but I would suspect that the NFL would want the bigger cities in Calgary and Montreal. So, I would straight up replace Edmonton with Calgary. To deal with Montreal I would move Indianapolis to Winnipeg's spot in the NFC Central, Pittsburgh to Indy's spot in the AFC Central, and put Montreal in Pittsburgh's spot in the AFC East. As for scheduling, I don't have great ideas for how to choose your two games in the other conference. If it was a 19 game schedule, you'd have room for three of those and you could take the three same-rank finishers. But this would create an unbalanced home/away breakdown. I love that you ended Thursday night football! I hate it for daily life and I think it is an (unfair) advantage to get to play in it. I am okay with Thanksgiving Thursday games but I would probably be happy to end NFL Thanksgiving and replace it with College games. Or Hockey. Or Basketball. Plus, Canada (new Canadian teams. eh?) celebrates Thanksgiving on a different date. I am good with post-college season Saturday games. I am fine with 7 playoff teams per conference but you will end up in a scheduling position that the league seems to be avoiding. With 7 teams (per CONF), there is only one bye (per CONF) thus three games in week one. With two such conferences, that means six games on the opening playoff weekend. That means triple-headers on both days or overlapping games. That would probably cause a future problem: what happens with more playoff expansion? (if the league grew even more? If it was decided that the only team to get a bye got too big of an advantage? If the NFL wanted more playoff money? If the teams pressed to let more teams make the tournament?) At 8 per side, that is eight games and almost certain overlap. Unless you added Friday night, or early morning games... Eight rounds of the draft is okay with me, but keep in mind that you are going deeper in the talent pool, especially as there are four more teams. I used to like to watch the draft but the NFL ruined it years ago, most notably by having too few rounds on night one and too long to make the picks. I would drop the time even more. 10 minutes, 8, 8, 8, 5, 5, 5, 5. Two days is great, definitely more than one round on day one, probably three rounds! I like compensatory picks as I think they can help a team (especially a smaller market team) from becoming a farm team for another (usually large market) team. I hate that they even play the Pro-Bowl. Just an opportunity for injury. |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
Though I don't necessarily agree with your alignment, I appreciate you actually answering the OP.
|
#22
|
||||
|
||||
No problem
Well, two problems; the digging out emails and typing took me around three hours, but it got done! And I made too many errors as I sped up at the end. |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
Thought of a couple things:
1) I'd have 2 Saturday games once they start, alternating 1/4 and 4/7 start times and alternating which network gets the early game 2) On Sundays the 1 PM window would have twice as many games as the 4 PM window. |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
Another clarification:
The interconference games for say, the AFCE, would rotate thusly: NFCE, NFCC NFCC, NFCW NFCE, NFCW AND alternate home/away |
#25
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
Ask the NHL: all the teams in the Metropolitan Division are, on average, closer to the Atlantic Ocean than the teams in the Atlantic Division. And let's not forget the 70s, when the Atlanta Braves were in the NL West and the Atlanta Falcons were in the NFC West. I grew up a Falcons fan until the Smith family pissed off my dad for the last time; he swore off the Falcons and hasn't cared about them since (I had the Steelers as my second team; they have been my "first team" since 1982). Anyway, people who grew up after realignment, or didn't care about the NFL\the Falcons wonder why I hate the 49ers and Rams almost as much as I hate the Ravens and Bengals! |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
Yeah, tunaman my alignment isn't ideal. Any general thoughts on my idea?
|
#27
|
|||
|
|||
I saw something about the NFL Draft today. My system moves it up a week.
|
#28
|
|||
|
|||
I realized that alternating Saturday doubleheaders means the same network gets the 4 o'clock game every week. So it makes sense to go with my 1st instinct of 1 Saturday game, but alternate 1pm and 4pm.
|
#29
|
|||
|
|||
Or it could just go to the network with a prime time package.
|
#30
|
|||
|
|||
Quote:
|
#31
|
|||
|
|||
Obvious Saturday solution
Tripleheaders 1/4/7
|
#32
|
|||
|
|||
Better AFCE
Flip Buffalo and Toronto with the Florida teams
|
#33
|
||||
|
||||
Here's an article on CBS Sports about the NFL owner's evolving position as it pertains to the schedule.
Maybe they've been reading this thread? |
#34
|
|||
|
|||
Another way to add four teams:
AFC EAST NEW ENGLAND NY JETS BUFFALO BALTIMORE PITTSBURGH MIAMI AFC CENTRAL CLEVELAND CINCINNATI TENNESSEE INDIANAPOLIS HOUSTON JACKSONVILLE AFC WEST KANSAS CITY DENVER SAN DIEGO (expansion) LOS ANGELES LAS VEGAS SAN ANTONIO (expansion) NFC EAST NY GIANTS WASHINGTON PHILADELPHIA CAROLINA ATLANTA TAMPA BAY NFC CENTRAL CHICAGO DETROIT GREEN BAY MINNESOTA ST LOUIS (expansion) NEW ORLEANS NFC WEST DALLAS ARIZONA SAN FRANCISCO LOS ANGELES SEATTLE PORTLAND (expansion) |
![]() |
|
|