Felt vs. MC: Mafia Day 2 Thread

[Zeener Diode]

Originally Posted by Giraffe

You are defending Romanic far more strongly than I'd expect a normal Town player to do. He's not a normal Mason, he's the role he claimed. So talking about the value Masons have in other games is inaccurate and obfuscatory at best.

I'm defending a potential Town Mason. I could be wrong about his alignment but I can't justify a vote on a claimed Town until it's clear they are not it. I could be defending moody because of his claimed doc role just as easy; the difference is that Romanic has "Miller" in his PM and that really bugs me.

Could you answer my questions about the value you see in Romanic's actual claimed role to Town? I don't see any, but you obviously do.

His value is no more than any other Mason, and obviously we can't call it that way in this game. Understandably, we don't know his true alignment but the practical thing is to side with the claim until reasons against them surface.

Until then, I'm going to operate on the theory that you two are scum buddies and you're trying to help him get out of the corner he's painted himself into with his role claim.

vote Zeener Diode from Day 7

I can't help you with that. You vote how you will. If my argument against a knee-jerk reactive vote on a claimed Miller (who is also a Mason) won't convince you of my reason NOT to vote, then there's not much more I can offer.