Felt vs. MC: Mafia Day 4 Thread - Page 2

Total Ulla · #51 11th March 2011, 01:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Giraffe

So, I'm going to vote for him. I recognize that this now looks super scummy, so I'll understand if everyone changes their vote from him to me, but I have to do what's best for Town even if it makes me look bad.

For once we agree very much - this is looking super scummy indeed!!!

Vote Giraffe from Day 7

moody mitchy · #52 11th March 2011, 06:26 AM

I'm going to be away until at least saturday evening possibly even longer but will be back before Day end due to work commitments...

I'd just like to say that if Lucifer flips SCUM and Giraffe flips TOWN , I'll be taking a very close look at those who were so keen to lynch Giraffe giving us in my opinion an uneccassary death...

Of course I could be wrong just like I feel that Giraffe was wrong in his unbending belief that Zeener Diode was SCUM

*Giraffe* · #53 11th March 2011, 07:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by moody mitchy

I'd just like to say that if Lucifer flips SCUM and Giraffe flips TOWN , I'll be taking a very close look at those who were so keen to lynch Giraffe giving us in my opinion an uneccassary death...

Actually, for Town Lucifer's alignment should be irrelevant in my lynching: he's dead no matter what. However, if I'm scum, then Town wants me dead toDay just to speed up the scum-killing process. If I'm Town, even highly suspect Town, Town wants me around as a human shield to slow down the loss of Townies while they sniff out the rest of the scum.

Just don't forget, while Town has a lot of good reasons to suspect I'm scum, the scum players know I'm Town. So they'll want me dead toDay if at all possible, but if any Town players have jumped in and led the drive to kill me, some of them can easily sit back and pretend to be unsure, thus giving themselves a nice alibi for the rest of the game. Smart scum players would have vote Lucifer early on, with the plan to either allow themselves to be convinced near the end by my scumminess or stay w. their Lucifer vote so they can point the finger at all the Giraffe bandwagoners.

One thing I find worrying is all the double voting. If it's Town doing it, we're burning up votes we may need for the endgame. If it's scum doing it, that probably means Lucifer is Town and this is them kicking hard for the win. I mean, Romola just used her Day 5 vote -- does this mean she's out of votes for the rest of the game? I think she double voted for me once before, I don't remember if she has a future vote left or not.

SisterCoyote · #54 11th March 2011, 07:54 AM

Okay, having gone back through the last few Days, I agree that Giraffe is looking the most scummiest.

Therefore.

*Giraffe* · #55 11th March 2011, 07:58 AM

Fair enough. I did expect to get lynched toDay after all.

I'm leaving my vote on Lucifer, as that is still the Towniest move, but it's clear I'm going to hang toDay. Alas.

Trepa Mayfield · #56 11th March 2011, 10:25 AM

With 2 Days, 10 hours and 6 minutes until the end of Day 4:

Vote Count:

Giraffe (7): Idle Thoughts [Day 4 Post 7], Total Ulla [Day 4 Post 20], Romola [Day 4 Post 21], Idle Thoughts [Day 6], Total Ulla [Day 7], Romola [Day 6], Sis Coyote [Day 4 Post 54]
Lucifer (3): BobArrgh [Day 4 Post 24], moody mitchy [Day 4 Post 27], Giraffe [Day 4 Post 35]

Not Voting: Lucifer

Voting from the Future: Romola [Day 6], Idle Thoughts [Day 6], Total Ulla [Day 7]

Total Ulla · #57 12th March 2011, 06:36 AM

No need to double vote when it seems Giraffe can be lynched without the extra votes.

Unvote my Day 7 vote on Giraffe

moody mitchy · #58 12th March 2011, 12:47 PM

Well I'm back I see I didn't miss much....

Still think it's a shame that people are happy for there to be 2 deaths toDay... when one could be avoided.

Yes I know you think he's SCUM but do you really think he's the last one ??

Even if you are right... SCUM will still get a kill in toNight.. I still think that the reason for lack of deaths at Night since Night one has something to do with Zuma's inactivity during this game... but I could always be wrong... guess I'll ckeck back at the end of the Day then to see who has been right...

Romola · #59 12th March 2011, 01:11 PM

What's the alternative, Moody? A scum death can't come soon enough for me, and I am sure that Giraffe is scum.

Romola · #60 12th March 2011, 01:13 PM

Oh, I object to the modkill of Lucifer - i think it will leave us a Town player down, and he DID ask to be subbed out, didn't he?

moody mitchy · #61 12th March 2011, 01:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Romola

Oh, I object to the modkill of Lucifer - i think it will leave us a Town player down, and he DID ask to be subbed out, didn't he?

Yes he asked to be subbed but one has not stepped forward hence the proposed mod kill.... I'd sooner have him lynched because otherwise it's a death that we don't need to have at the moment.

I'm sorry that I don't share peoples belief that Giraffe is SCUM but that's just my take on it for which if others are right... then I shall bow down to their greater wisdom... I still just feel that he had this unbending feeling that Zeener Diode was a better SCUM candidate... he was wrong... we've all known that feeling along the line somewhere..

I'm also a little frustrated that to me it seems people have decided the best candidate... placed their votes and are now happy to sit back and wait for Day end without any further discussion.

I thought talk was god in these games... information is what we need or even evidence of a slip... to help us choose who we might go after next.

Romola · #62 12th March 2011, 01:58 PM

It's gone way beyond the double voting for zeener, his behaviour since being voted has been so scummy as to be super scummy. If we definitely have to lynch Luci sooner or later, i would rather wait till there is no more obvious scum than there is today. As things stand, there are 2 people (including Giraffe) I would lynch before I even looked at Luci. I don't want him mod killed.

Better make that official

Objection to modkilling Lucifer

*Giraffe* · #63 12th March 2011, 02:44 PM

Romola, my biggest worry now is that you're Town, which I'm thinking will pretty much clinch the win for scum when I flip, as you've taken such a strong position against both me and the Lucifer mod-kill. (Which would indirectly make me responsible for nearly every stage of Town's loss. Go me!

)

I'm also a bit puzzled by your refusal to answer questions this game -- in past games, you've always been quite forthright. But, what the hey, I'll ask it again anyway: are you really using your last vote of the game to double-vote me? If you're Town, why would you put yourself in a position of having no votes between now and the rest of the game?

Trepa Mayfield · #64 12th March 2011, 04:03 PM

With 1 Days, 3 hours and 25 minutes until the end of Day 4:

Vote Count:

Giraffe (6): Idle Thoughts [Day 4 Post 7], Total Ulla [Day 4 Post 20], Romola [Day 4 Post 21], Idle Thoughts [Day 6], Romola [Day 6], Sis Coyote [Day 4 Post 54]
Lucifer (3): BobArrgh [Day 4 Post 24], moody mitchy [Day 4 Post 27], Giraffe [Day 4 Post 35]

Not Voting: Lucifer

Voting from the Future: Romola [Day 6], Idle Thoughts [Day 6]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Romola

It's gone way beyond the double voting for zeener, his behaviour since being voted has been so scummy as to be super scummy. If we definitely have to lynch Luci sooner or later, i would rather wait till there is no more obvious scum than there is today. As things stand, there are 2 people (including Giraffe) I would lynch before I even looked at Luci. I don't want him mod killed.

Better make that official

Objection to modkilling Lucifer

Noted.

Romola · #65 12th March 2011, 05:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Giraffe

Romola, my biggest worry now is that you're Town, which I'm thinking will pretty much clinch the win for scum when I flip, as you've taken such a strong position against both me and the Lucifer mod-kill. (Which would indirectly make me responsible for nearly every stage of Town's loss. Go me!

)

I'm also a bit puzzled by your refusal to answer questions this game -- in past games, you've always been quite forthright. But, what the hey, I'll ask it again anyway: are you really using your last vote of the game to double-vote me? If you're Town, why would you put yourself in a position of having no votes between now and the rest of the game?

I'll take the extra vote off before the ned of day if you will certainly get lynched without it. But I'm not prepared to take the chance of letting you or your scummy backside off the noose until i am certain of your lynch. If I take it off now, your scumbuddy/ies will certainly take theirs off last minute.

Town loss? Not a chance, matey.

*Giraffe* · #66 12th March 2011, 05:30 PM

But am I correct that it's your last vote left, i.e. you've already used Day 6 and 7's votes?

Romola · #67 13th March 2011, 03:36 AM

No, the extra on you today is Day 6 and I've used either my Day 5 or Day 7 vote extra on you YesterDay. If I pull that off, i will still have Day 6 plus one other vote. If I don't, I will still have one vote. You are very solicitous about my votes, G.

Romola · #68 13th March 2011, 03:39 AM

NETA - toDay's extra vote on you is actually from Day 5. I used my Day 6 one on you YesterDay. So if I am able to pull off my Day 5 vote from you, i will still have that plus my Day 7 vote.

*Giraffe* · #69 13th March 2011, 08:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Romola

No, the extra on you today is Day 6 and I've used either my Day 5 or Day 7 vote extra on you YesterDay. If I pull that off, i will still have Day 6 plus one other vote. If I don't, I will still have one vote. You are very solicitous about my votes, G.

Thanks for answering. And you'd do the same in my shoes, if you thought another player was burning up all their votes by Day 4.

Romola · #70 13th March 2011, 11:31 AM

Am i right in thinking we have about 9 1/2 hours to Day end? I think I will have to get up uber early in the morning to catch it, but it's doable. Debating the risk of sleeping in and missing it.

moody mitchy · #71 13th March 2011, 02:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Romola

Am i right in thinking we have about 9 1/2 hours to Day end? I think I will have to get up uber early in the morning to catch it, but it's doable. Debating the risk of sleeping in and missing it.

Well I doubt very much that there will be a huge turnaround between now and then... It's pretty safe that Giraffe is going to swing.

Just a shame that people haven't bothered trying to further discussion and find out more information.

BobArrgh · #72 13th March 2011, 02:24 PM

How can Romola have a vote from D6 if she already pulled a vote from D6 on D3?

BobArrgh · #73 13th March 2011, 02:29 PM

NETA: Ah, I see it now ... Romola pulled in a vote from D5 in post #37 toDay. That was what she meant in her #68.

Romola · #74 13th March 2011, 02:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by moody mitchy

Quote:

Originally Posted by Romola

Am i right in thinking we have about 9 1/2 hours to Day end? I think I will have to get up uber early in the morning to catch it, but it's doable. Debating the risk of sleeping in and missing it.

Well I doubt very much that there will be a huge turnaround between now and then... It's pretty safe that Giraffe is going to swing.....

You may very well think so, Moody, but i strongly suspect at least one Giraffe voter of being scum and thus liable to pull off the vote if it looks as if they can swing the lynch. They have had the advantage of being around at end of Day so far.

BobArrgh · #75 13th March 2011, 04:04 PM

@Romola: Im not sure I following your argument, but it's prossibly be the pain meds. (I was doing some drywall work at my house yesterday and pulled a muscle in my back. The Tramadol is taking care of the pain but ding nothing for my cognitive skills)

Sorry. I had some thoughts about your concerns in #74 but cant figure our what I was questoning.

@moody: I was reading toDay and you used the term "lylo" in post #13. What does taht mean?

Romola · #76 13th March 2011, 04:17 PM

Bob, lylo is lynch or lose. The deciding stage in a game.

I am worried that if I am not around at the end of Day, and have already taken my extra vote from Giraffe, that his scum buddies will lift theirs and lynch Lucifer instead. Does that put it any clearer?

Romola · #77 13th March 2011, 04:22 PM

Ok guys, I'm gong to bed and leaving the extra vote on. If I manage to get up in time to see if i can safely lift it, I will. Otherwise, I hope to see you all toNight with a dead scum Giraffe.

BobArrgh · #78 13th March 2011, 05:09 PM

Thanks for clarfying, romola.

*Giraffe* · #79 13th March 2011, 06:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Romola

Otherwise, I hope to see you all toNight with a dead scum Giraffe.

Enjoy your disappointment...

BobArrgh · #80 13th March 2011, 06:49 PM

Why? Dont think youll die?

BobArrgh · #81 13th March 2011, 07:23 PM

BobArrgh · #82 13th March 2011, 07:25 PM

Idle Thoughts · #83 13th March 2011, 07:28 PM

Unvote Giraffe from Day 6

BobArrgh · #84 13th March 2011, 07:29 PM

BobArrgh · #85 13th March 2011, 07:29 PM

Trepa Mayfield · #86 13th March 2011, 07:32 PM

Day 4 Final Vote Count:

Vote Count:

Giraffe (5): Idle Thoughts [Day 4 Post 7], Total Ulla [Day 4 Post 20], Romola [Day 4 Post 21], Romola [Day 5], Sis Coyote [Day 4 Post 54]
Lucifer (3): BobArrgh [Day 4 Post 85], moody mitchy [Day 4 Post 27], Giraffe [Day 4 Post 35]

Not Voting: Lucifer

Voting from the Future: Romola [Day 5]