The Giraffe Boards - Search Results

Views: 12,527

Posted By The Gazebo

And, now that I've seen the notifications,...

And, now that I've seen the notifications, Eileen's questions as well. That will not be tonight though, since I'm traveling and my plane will probably board in ten minutes or so.

Forum: The Dungeon

12th October 2018, 07:34 PM

Replies: 453

Views: 12,527

Posted By The Gazebo

Well, that's a relief - I still have to catch up...

Well, that's a relief - I still have to catch up and answer PurpleWorm's questions.

Forum: The Dungeon

11th October 2018, 05:17 AM

Replies: 453

Views: 12,527

Posted By The Gazebo

Not necessarily - it reminds me of the game...

Not necessarily - it reminds me of the game Diplomacy, where all moves take place simultaneously, but the success of these moves has a set of rules that determine whether a move fails or succeeds.

Forum: The Dungeon

11th October 2018, 05:13 AM

Replies: 453

Views: 12,527

Posted By The Gazebo

I'm finding it easier to try to think of who I...

I'm finding it easier to try to think of who I see as posting and thinking in a townish way, and then just voting everyone who doesn't meet those criteria:

Vote Orge Jelly

Alan_Tudyk
...

Forum: The Dungeon

9th October 2018, 08:25 PM

Replies: 453

Views: 12,527

Posted By The Gazebo

Yeah - I agree with this, the whole Monster...

Yeah - I agree with this, the whole Monster schtick is Evil or possibly Chaotic Good alignments. I would imagine anyone with a Lawful Good or Neutral Good alignment is not a Monster, and therefore...

Forum: The Dungeon

9th October 2018, 04:11 PM

Replies: 453

Views: 12,527

Posted By The Gazebo

Any significant reason for this belief? Or is it...

Any significant reason for this belief? Or is it just a hunch?

BTW, welcome, Eileen Dover!

Forum: The Dungeon

9th October 2018, 04:10 PM

Replies: 453

Views: 12,527

Posted By The Gazebo

Well, at least I now know which side my primary...

Well, at least I now know which side my primary suspect was on. Sadly, that doesn't inspire me with confidence regarding my other picks. :sciencefail:

I'm in favor of the mass claim. Not because I...

Forum: The Dungeon

9th October 2018, 04:12 AM

Replies: 39

Night Two -- Monster Manual Mafia

Views: 2,571

Posted By The Gazebo

Maybe not the best thing to ask for answers at...

Maybe not the best thing to ask for answers at Night, but for follow-up the next Day, I agree to keep this in mind.

Mordenkainen - did you ever figure out your vote picture for yesterDay? And you...

Forum: The Dungeon

8th October 2018, 05:25 PM

Replies: 39

Night Two -- Monster Manual Mafia

Views: 2,571

Posted By The Gazebo

So 15 remaining living players, with a...

So 15 remaining living players, with a Monster:Hero ratio somewhere between 2:1 and 4:1? Unless there was mention in the set-up threads about how many Heroes there would be?

In a slower-paced...

Forum: The Dungeon

8th October 2018, 06:04 AM

Replies: 268

Views: 5,938

Posted By The Gazebo

I don't believe we can possibly know this - we...

I don't believe we can possibly know this - we don't know why they were targeted, or even by whom they were targeted (was one a Vig?) - we can't really know that No Lynch voting had anything to do...

Forum: The Dungeon

8th October 2018, 04:01 AM

Replies: 268

Views: 5,938

Posted By The Gazebo

Well, I can't argue with that. ...

Well, I can't argue with that.

Could you elaborate at all? I've got vichyssoise down as potentially town - seems to be engaged with others' vote reasoning/arguing and attempting to figure...

Forum: The Dungeon

7th October 2018, 09:14 PM

Replies: 268

Views: 5,938

Posted By The Gazebo

I know the question wasn't directed at me, but I...

I know the question wasn't directed at me, but I feel like if nothing happened in the filibuster time, it's hard to imagine that scum were online ready to defend Jeopardy but refusing to do so. It's...

Forum: The Dungeon

7th October 2018, 09:13 PM

Replies: 268

Views: 5,938

Posted By The Gazebo

I belly-flopped on that second Eater of Socks...

I belly-flopped on that second Eater of Socks link, it should have been this: http://www.giraffeboards.com/showpost.php?p=1478094&postcount=120

Forum: The Dungeon

7th October 2018, 09:10 PM

Replies: 268

Views: 5,938

Posted By The Gazebo

Unvote No Lynch Just because it seems...

Unvote No Lynch

Just because it seems easier, I get the general impression that Owlbear, Erinyes, Mad Mage, and vichyssoise are more townish/Monsterish than others. I could very well be wrong, and...

Forum: The Dungeon

4th October 2018, 08:33 PM

Replies: 268

Views: 5,938

Posted By The Gazebo

Ugh. If we're voting anyone, I don't think...

Ugh. If we're voting anyone, I don't think Owlbear is the best target.

Vote No Lynch (also helps if the filibuster doesn't pass)

Forum: The Dungeon

4th October 2018, 08:30 PM

Replies: 268

Views: 5,938

Posted By The Gazebo

Vote Filibuster Darn houseguests consider it...

Vote Filibuster

Darn houseguests consider it rude if I play mafia at them.

Forum: The Dungeon

2nd October 2018, 08:35 PM

Replies: 268

Views: 5,938

Posted By The Gazebo

As much as I'd like to take advantage of the...

As much as I'd like to take advantage of the situation, this is clearly true. Without knowing more about what's going on, it'd be suspicious if anyone but me believed that message uncritically.

Forum: The Dungeon

28th September 2018, 06:55 AM

Replies: 319

Views: 12,728

Posted By The Gazebo

I am concerned about this, I have no concern...

I am concerned about this, I have no concern about hiding who I usually am - I thought about trying to change my post style, and that would just take too much energy. Plus posting in character as The...

Forum: The Dungeon

27th September 2018, 04:43 AM

Replies: 319

Views: 12,728

Posted By The Gazebo

I think a bunch of claims nearing the lynch is...

I think a bunch of claims nearing the lynch is probably inevitable - this was billed as a game with a lot of powers in it. We'll just have to accept that whoever we vote to lynch is likely to have a...

Forum: The Dungeon

26th September 2018, 02:37 PM

Replies: 319

Views: 12,728

Posted By The Gazebo

I'm uncomfortable with this as an analysis from...

I'm uncomfortable with this as an analysis from the viewpoint of an individual player's survival rather than that of a team. But I am reading this from the viewpoint of you saying "this is what...

Forum: The Dungeon

26th September 2018, 05:12 AM

Replies: 319

Views: 12,728

Posted By The Gazebo

Voting for someone else is meaningless if we know...

Voting for someone else is meaningless if we know the group is going to decide on No Lynch - we don't yet, and I wouldn't propose that we make No Lynch a certainty.

Forum: The Dungeon

25th September 2018, 09:36 PM

Replies: 319

Views: 12,728

Posted By The Gazebo

Does anyone treat the vote record as if it can't...

Does anyone treat the vote record as if it can't be tainted by bussing? I don't think we play mafia that way, and it doesn't make any sense to try.

We (or enough of us) vote No Lynch if we think...

Forum: The Dungeon

25th September 2018, 08:32 PM

Replies: 319

Views: 12,728

Posted By The Gazebo

That's why I think the No Lynch voters should all...

That's why I think the No Lynch voters should all at least be voting one other player in addition to voting No Lynch.

Forum: The Dungeon

25th September 2018, 08:19 PM

Replies: 319

Views: 12,728

Posted By The Gazebo

This is a multi-voting game. We can still vote...

This is a multi-voting game. We can still vote for No Lynch and vote for someone!

Forum: The Dungeon

25th September 2018, 07:30 PM

Replies: 319