[guiri]

Originally Posted by LightFoot

guiri some of your 'takes' on my comments are off base- but you see things the way you see them-( most of the time you are rather accurate) I am not tunneling- ( if we share the same definition) I have not, however, seen anything to make me think that lulz is not Scum

OK, but is it possible you've latched on to his lack of a response as a reason to vote him so it's not purely a punishment vote?

Originally Posted by lulz

You see, game mechanics discussion is wasting time and doesn't actually move the game forward. Game mechanics discussion provides everyone with just as much information as discussing magic horses. However while a discussion about magic horses is obviously not productive and nobody would pretend it is such, setup speculation can masquerade as a productive discussion and can be used to pretend to be busy when really you're not doing anything at all.

I think anyone would agree that discussing game mechanics is more relevant, meaningful, and potentially useful, than flying horses. There could have been a handshake opportunity/slip with the wincon, some players may have had no idea about the expected number of scum, some may not have know about third parties or PFKs, some may have had useful or additional non-revealing information about the color. As for actually using the information discussed to make a case, I think that's an unfair expectation, and would be limited to scum slips, PIS or focus on mechanics over hunting scum...

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

DO NOT FORCE ME TO CLAIM

This is either unreasonable or unnecessary, you're saying they are Town but you're not a cop, not masons, that leaves a bluff, some weird and wonderful role I've not considered like a watcher who learns the class of action taken, or scum. I don't think lulz is scum, but you could be snuggling wildly. Are you trying to muddy the waters? I'm still orange for you so you're probably not looking for my help but if you are, should I move from Double A because you have role-related reasons to believe he's town? Or should I put faith and trust in your reads? Or should I continue playing my own game and vote who pings me the most?

Scathach
- D1 contributions were to remind some of us that lulz' behavior here was identical to the previous game where he was Town and to vote Double A for focusing on Drinkie's absence but not hers. I'm not sure what exactly rubbed Pizza the wrong way about her early contributions but he voted her in #94. Blending in? Voting based on logical arguments?
- D2 doesn't think lulz is scummy, finds his meta game voters oogly, still suspects DoubleA, posts about Zeener's resurrection, asks Pizza why he's voting her, doesn't see it
- My case on DoubleA is almost the same as hers, the arguments used against her vote should apply to me but even DoubleA reads us as opposites, I'm not seeing much else from her but she's not pinging me wildly