Quote:
Originally Posted by Precambrianmollusc
Quote:
Originally Posted by gnarlycharlie
PM received.
because I missed him and he because he mentions 3rd parties when there's no mention of any in the rules or color.
|
Sure , he pointed that you seemd to have more information.
Yes as scum he may have missed the plural in the VT post. I missed the plural as did apparently Colby |
I asked you to go back because he was replying to my comment on a post where I quoted the VT role PM:
Quote:
Originally Posted by guiri
Quote:
Originally Posted by Eristic Widgeon
Welcome to the game, you are Vanilla Town.
You have no special powers except for your voice and your vote.
You win when all anti-Town forces have been eliminated.
|
With 14 players, maybe 3 scum and one third party.
Not much else to go on from the color or rules. |
Quote:
|
What I found suspicious of you was that you did not really provide any alternatives other than must be scum. I have no idea what gnarliy is , but can see there are multiple possibilities
|
Also demonstrably false:
Quote:
Originally Posted by guiri
Gnarly is unlikely 3P but could be scum if there’s no mention of other anti-town forces in his wincon. I don’t give townie points for an erroneous gotcha vote, no matter how early, both Gnarly and Colby had access to the sample VT role PM and wincon.
|
And if I was sure he was scum, and had actually made a case against him, that’s where my vote would be, but I’m not, and have not, so it’s not.