The Poop Deck unspoiled chat

[Vanta Black]

Living players stay off!




And no, the poop deck is not where you take the dogs. It is on top of the cabin area and provides an elevated position ideal for observation. Good place to watch the action and comment on it, if you so desire.

[Colby11]

I feel that the Pleo lynch wagon is being scum driven, or at least there is a scum there.

Not sure who I would vote for... maybe Bashian with him talking to himself...

[SNFaulkner]

I'm getting the Jackbox game Joke Boat vibes from the narrative, but in a good way.

[Dead Cat]

I've only had time to skim a few pages of this (which means it's just as well I'm not playing), but it looks great fun - as usual, wish I was involved.

[Colby11]

Originally Posted by Dead Cat

I've only had time to skim a few pages of this (which means it's just as well I'm not playing), but it looks great fun - as usual, wish I was involved.

Same, which is why I’ve been adding color as the menu planner... but I don’t think that I needed to play

[Mahaloth]

Disappointing, especially after I avoided getting launched the previous Day. I was caught, but I honestly thought that there was going to be a much more severe consequence for no-launch. Town got another chance to re-do Day 2 with zero consequence to them for failing to launch.

It actually felt more like a reward to them than a punishment.

[Prof. Pepperwinkle]

Great fun game. Well done, Vanta!

[Mahaloth]

I'm happy to speak about the game here, but am also happy to go to the spoiled chat if there is one.

[Prof. Pepperwinkle]

.--. ..-. ..- ..

[Prof. Pepperwinkle]

I have no clue who is Scum at all. This is a great game.

[Pleonast]

Originally Posted by Prof. Pepperwinkle

I have no clue who is Scum at all.

Scum tell!

Town made a huge tactical mistake by not using BillMc's power list. We could have forced scum to make hard claims about their powers and thus restrict their options the following Night. And risks to town for doing it are low this game because if a player is killed, someone else could inherit the power. The whole game of mafia is clever use of the bits of information we get, and town left it on the barrel head. Besides the anti-town bias of the voting system, I blame this mistake for our impending loss.

I think Lion is playing very scummy. See the revisionist history they post in Day Five. But should not be launched because of Silverjan's result. Well played!

Archangel definitely looks at scum motivation for Night kills differently than I do. This points to a tactical weakness in their play, but one that is common among players here. Am I the only one who advocates for random kills? Anyway, more likely to be town than scum. I feel like they're trying to solve the game.

BillMc has been playing townie, but that's meaningless.

The fact that LightFoot has tied together the three of them really helps solve the game. I wish they had more time to spend on it.

raventhief has been even more absent than LightFoot. I feel their play is not quite townie-tell, but sure feels like town, in a positive way, unlike BillMc. We really need some more help from them.

The facts of Bashorian Clement all point toward scum. Maybe I'm wrong, but it's the type of wrong I'm always going to vote.

My assessment of sturmhauke is town, but there's no other place to put the third scum. Sometimes the numbers get you. Well played, either way.

[Meeko]

[sturmhauke]

This game has been confusing as hell.

Sent from my SM-G986U using Tapatalk