Vegas Mafia Day Four

[Askthepizzaguy]

Originally Posted by Bashorian Clement

I can't track the dynamic between Meeko and Kaiveran, but it seems Meeko is suspicious of Kaiveran so I'm riding a bit on that too.

Originally Posted by Bashorian Clement

Now that I think about it I'm not sure I want to hitch my horse to that buggy but let's see how it playhs out.

This doesn't track well with BC's conclusion in the previous post about how the town hider may have found a scum mechanically.

BC's own opinion about Kai's guilt by mechanical likelihood should be more important than how Meeko feels about it, especially without a negative opinion on Meeko. At last mention, Meeko was a town read.

I do not follow the process here, even if the conclusion was good. This process arrives at a good decision, states the mechanics as to why it was a good decision, and works backwards toward doubting the decision is good based on how Meeko, a town read, feels about it.

Exactly the same process that happened when Vanta had been blocked and his target was jailed in the clowns game, Vanta's partners arrived at the correct conclusion before town did, then worked backwards to arrive at doubt.

It's fine to doubt your suspicions, but the reason given is that a town read agrees with it. That doesn't help me read BC town.